Facebook LogoIf individuals receive e-mails they don’t want, they’re given the opportunity to take their names off of mailing lists (as part of 2003’s CAN-SPAM Act). The same is true in several other circumstances. If people don’t want telemarketers calling their house, they can put their names on the National Do Not Call Registry. But what are internet users to do when they find new and obtrusive features foisted upon them?

Case Study #1 – ‘Opt Out Done Right': Yahoo!

Yahoo!, as part of their new Mail Beta, allows users to utilize the old interface if they’re not satisfied with the new one. Similarly, users can switch to the new beta interface and use it without paying attention to the old, non-AJAX interface. Yahoo seems to have kept users happy with this move, but it may not be funneling enough users to the new, snazzier product. Clearly, this is because Yahoo gives its members a choice. It’s a question of better or worse, with the new Yahoo Mail Beta being a lot better than the old interface Yahoo provided. Still, in the interest of choice, Yahoo allows their userbase to make the decision on their own.

Yahoo Mail Option

Yahoo! Gives Users the Option to Switch to a New Interface (Emphasis Added)

Case Study #2 – ‘You Belong to Us': Facebook

Facebook, however, has gone about their Application Platform a bit differently. Instead of giving their users the option to switch to the new Application Platform, Facebook has instead instituted the changes across every user account, not giving any of the users a say in the switch. Without a doubt, this quick, mandatory alteration has enabled Facebook to transform its millions of users into Platform users. The change allowed Facebook to force users to notice the new Platform. Without the official change, use of the API and the tools Facebook provided may have stagnated due to a slow-to-adapt userbase.

Facebook’s Options

Some users, however, aren’t so happy about Facebook’s new system. Some are heralding the arrival of MySpace-type features, decrying the new Platform’s changes. Nobody can deny that the new Platform has made Facebook a busier place. The application sidebar, along with people’s profile pages, have suddenly become more and more cluttered with applications. While some users can minimize the applications on a case-by-case basis, there is no cure-all for the distraction the applications provide from Facebook’s general interface.

Minimized Apps

A Set of Minimized Apps on a Facebook Profile. While Smaller, the Applications Still Occupy Lots of Room.

Instead, I propose that Facebook creates an “opt-out” program. This way, users that aren’t thrilled with the Platform can remove it and go back to their normal Facebook browsing habits. Meanwhile, Facebook can continue to run the Application Platform on everyone else’s profiles. This way, the users unhappy with the changes wouldn’t have to deal with the hassle of applications on their profile or with the eyesore of applications on their friends’ profiles.

Opt Out

Will Facebook Allow Users to Opt Out of its Applications?


But will Facebook change? The company is notoriously responsive to user feedback, but I don’t think there’s enough of a movement to create the kind of change I’m talking about. As Facebook grows, the group opposed to the Platform may grow, forcing Facebook to adopt a similar solution to the one suggested above.

Written by | dave

No Description or Default Description Here



  1. Stuart Robertson

    June 27, 2007 at 6:33 am

    The new Face Off Extension for Firefox allows users to opt-out of viewing the new 3rd Party applications:


  2. cat

    June 29, 2007 at 12:07 am

    “As Facebook grows, the group opposed to the Platform may grow, forcing Facebook to adopt a similar solution to the one suggested above.”

    Actually, I think that the growth Facebook is currently experiencing is due mostly to the new platform, which has added utility to a site that, for many, served no real important purpose previously. While the addition of so many applications to try may have sparked a frenzy and resulted in convoluted profile pages initially, I have a feeling that most mature users will eventually discard those that don’t really provide added functionality.

    It is strange to me that anyone would not find at least one useful application.

  3. the reliable life insurance company

    October 17, 2008 at 6:21 pm

    Just dropping in to let you know you have an interesting site. I hope you’ll continue to work on it. Wishing you all the best.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply