A search engine which has been making waves in the blogosphere for the last day or two is Cuil (pronounced “cool”). You’ve probably used it twice already, and its random search results (in some cases, the worst ever served by a search engine) do less to serve and more to amaze. I made up my mind this morning to not write about Cuil since I think it had been written about a little too much, but now it hardly seems like it matters.

For you slowpokes, the back story of Cuil is that it was started by a couple ex-Googlers who played a crucial part in what Google search is today, they raised $30 million for the startup and brought on board more Googlers, who have then built a search engine with an index of 125 billion pages (supposedly more than Google’s) and close to 1% relevancy, though no one is judging since it is, literally, their first day on the job.

I think what’s more interesting than the search engine itself, which is like any other “kill Google” new-search-engine-on-the-block, is the question of whether we need another Google, and if it is theoritically possible for someone to create a search engine which has results 25% – 50% better than Google’s and get 1 billion people to switch to it.

Robert Scoble doesn’t think so. He argues, “I still doubt many people would switch. Why? Distribution. Huh? Well, my Firefox browser has Google built into it. Most people have no idea how to switch it. Most people, on our tests, really don’t understand much of anything except that that little box probably now goes to Google. The Google. It’s so pervasive of an expectation at this point that many people type URLs into that box. Or, type the word “Yahoo” into that box so they can get to their email and other Yahoo services. Is Cuil going to be able to get into this game? No way, no how.

I think Scoble is right on the dot, as close-minded as it sounds. Cuil’s problem isn’t relevancy, even given that it has cracked it. Cuil’s problem is distribution. Mass, billion user-level distribution. We like to think that the market place will at all costs reward anything which is better than something else, but I simply don’t think this will be the case should a real Google-killer arrive (and Cuil isn’t it). Instead, here is how I think it will more likely happen:

  • Google killer arrives.
  • Early adopters try it out, like it, have luck with it. Love it.
  • Google killer gets bought by Microsoft and is never to be heard of again, found later as a part of Live.

And that’s the sad and depressing fact of being a 21st century Google-killer. See, when Google took over AltaVista, the situation was very different. Unlike Google, AltaVista sucked. They had cracked probably a 25% relevancy rate, which is close to being the only market option at the time. Google did 50%, eventually people noticed it, and AltaVista is not to be heard of today.

Which brings me to Cuil (or any Google killer’s) problem: Google today is probably about 90% relevant. This means it satisfies probably 90% of people’s searches on the Internet, that is of course, given the appropriate and relevant pages exist. This means, though you may have better search results than Google, Google is going to work 90% of the time regardless of its second-grade search results, and as a result, 90% of the people on this planet have no reason to care about you.

So let’s say a search engine cracks 100%. The result: as long as Google’s relevancy doesn’t degrade over time, or they are overwhelmed somehow by spam overnight, Google ain’t moving. 70%+ search dominance, we’re still alive! This is because of one simple reason: distribution. Google has manage to crack distribution, branding, presence, while being “just good enough,” and this is all the world asks from a search engine — no 100% relevancy, nothing else.

But that is not to say that all hope is lost for aspiring Google killers. I think if you can crack, firstly, 90%+ relevancy, and secondly, a user interface which is as close to what Google’s own was at its time, which says a lot seeing that it’s remained the same for 10 years, and if you can resist the temptation of a $100 million – $400 million buyout from Steve Ballmer, you may have something in your hands. And then, it would be a long wait — maybe years — till you can get even a fraction of the distribution and scaling that Google has, but after that, you will have a Google killer in your hands.

The chances of that happening of course is very unlikely. What is more likely is a growing pool of aspiring Google killers in the market, and, as a result, a growing pool of possible acquisitions for Microsoft to choose from. My prediction: Microsoft gobbles gobbles gobbles through this growing pool, and eventually Live Search is as good as Google’s, but distribution is yet to be cracked. In other words: Google remains king.

Written by | dave

No Description or Default Description Here



  1. Anonymous

    September 6, 2011 at 8:59 am

    ugg classic boots are not only varied in styles, but also in colors. Among them, ugg chestnutchocolate uggsBailey Button Uggs Sand and Bailey Button Uggs black are most favored by lovers of ugg classic short. It is well known that many ugg outlet stores are preparing quite a lot of kids uggs and women ugg boots for the coming of chilly winter, and the ugg chestnutchocolate uggsBailey Button Uggs Sand and Bailey Button Uggs black will always be the attention not only in the eyes of fashion circle, but also of the common people.

  2. Panpan010

    September 7, 2011 at 3:04 am

    Before the transfer
    window closed, real Madrid finally off Leon-pedro.


    (indy colts )

    (Cheap jerseys)

    (Football jerseys)

    (Nfl authentic

    (Jerseys for cheap)

    in a years on the court, Leon
    first by jose mourinho’s discontent, then there was banned under coach, there
    was more to crazy during their population out but team-mate pepe play gigged

    Gonzalez jerseys)

    (Antoine Bethea jerseys)

    (Austin Collie jerseys)

    (Bob Sanders jerseys)

    with reference to the lazio blocked goran pandev finally win

    (Dallas Clark jerseys)

    (Donald Brown jerseys)

    (Dwight Freeney jerseys)

    (Gary Brackett jerseys)

    have estimated that, Leon
    could very well win the lawsuit, and the net result is that real Madrid have to pay in

    (Johnny Unitas jerseys)

    (Joseph Addai jerseys)

    (Peyton Manning jerseys)

    (Pierre Garcon jerseys)

    (Reggie Wayne jerseys)

    (Robert Mathis jerseys)

    mourinho and the rest of Asia real Madrid
    contract and five years.


  3. cheapshoesbag

    September 8, 2011 at 5:41 pm

    We are an online shop specialized in supplying cheap jerseys, wholesale nfl jerseys, nhl jerseys etc. We also customize cheap jerseys for our customers. Our jerseys are well-received by old and new customers with the high quality and satisfactory service. We are dedicated to provide you with the best products, the cheapest prices, the most timely delivery and 24 hours online customer service. We guarantee that, in similar products, we are the most affordable! Welcome to inquire and make orders. Please visit our web: http://www.jerseygate.com 

  4. louboutins

    September 14, 2011 at 1:53 am

    Girls winter cold but do not dare to wear too much, afraid of bloated, how to do
    it? Our Moncler
    shop network teach you choose for your Moncler
    coats, to create winter weight loss moncler! Down has always been a
    love-hate relationship the girls clothes, when cold will certainly remember it,
    but the thought of wearing it becomes very “big only”, gave up the desire to buy
    it. Haha, in fact, do not worry, you can dress moncler
    vest nice and thin, look at the following real demonstration of
    it!We have sell cheap
    Moncler jackets in Moncler Online
    Shop.There are all kinds of Moncler
    jackets.For example of Moncler
    Women and so on.

  5. wholesale nfl jerseys

    September 15, 2011 at 7:51 am

    What also make fans depressed was the “black”
    wholesale nfl jerseys of England team. The team’s low tones jersey dominated the audience. That is the new England away cheap mlb jerseys in 2011-12 season. The black shirt and black socks with blue between blue pants. Unlike past white and red jersey, the colors are on a heavy style. The specially designed with a small section of blue-collar does not reduce heaviness of black.

  6. Anonymous

    September 15, 2011 at 9:47 am

    I think the google is one of the powerful tool
    Cheap Jerseys Wholesale
    Green Bay Packers Jerseys
    Pittsburgh Steelers Jerseys

  7. Stock Biken

    September 21, 2011 at 9:14 am

    They need help to educate tham about business and protecting their livelihoods.
    They need help to educate tham about business and protecting their livelihoods.

  8. Geageag

    September 30, 2011 at 7:34 am

    cheap jerseys
    cheap soccer jerseys
    cheap nfl jerseys
    wholesale soccer jerseys
    cheap soccer jerseys
    Valuable information and excellent design you got here! I would like to thank you for sharing your thoughts and time into the stuff you post!!    Thumbs up
    soccer jerseys
    discount soccer jerseys

  9. uggbootssale uggbootssale

    November 1, 2011 at 7:21 am

    Type your comment here.uggs boots outlet
    uggs boots.
    moncler outlet

  10. uggbootssale uggbootssale

    November 1, 2011 at 7:21 am

  11. uggbootssale uggbootssale

    November 1, 2011 at 7:21 am

  12. cheap sports hats

    November 1, 2011 at 9:41 am

    Perhaps this is one of the most interesting blogs that I have ever seen. Interesting article, Funny comment. Keep it up!

  13. Leemumu Lee7

    November 28, 2011 at 7:27 am

    Search our site and and begin saving on Callahan #24 New York Rangers jerseys at nfl jerseys factory
    with 6 years of wholesale experience, we are 24 hours online service. its easy to work with and offer a full money back guarantee on the quality
    of each display.

  14. Hao12352sd

    November 29, 2011 at 9:39 am

  15. best seo forums

    February 1, 2012 at 11:08 am

    Good post. Keep up your work done..

  16. Michael Kors

    March 30, 2012 at 8:02 am

    Regardless of man’s age, hermes belt mens watches present both classically refined and vintage inspired. Despite searching opulent, michael kors outlet.net stretch and play with their color hues from black pave crystals adorning round bezel to white ceramic bezel embellish with numeric engraving. 

  17. JerseysHome

    March 31, 2012 at 9:30 am

    i like it

  18. Anonymous

    April 16, 2012 at 1:30 am

    superdry outlet online For the Road Ahead
    coach outlet store online Let us make things better
    nike heels Generation Next
    coach factory outlet Time is what you make of it
    requin nike tn Connecting People  
    coach factory online For the Road Ahead

  19. cheap handbags

    June 20, 2012 at 6:45 am

    Designed with excellent craftsmanship, noble taste and latest style, every cheap handbag is hot selling with a large discount. With a great variety of cheap handbags to choose from, you can certainly get your favorite cheap handbag of top quality and competitive price . Since we were engaged in selling cheap handbags, we have paid much attention to both function and fashion of every handbag. Therefore, you can be assured that cheap handbag are convenient, trendy and attractive whenever and wherever.

  20. Echo012

    June 21, 2012 at 7:20 am

    :The leather shoulder bag is a more official design of the leather shoulder bag. A leather shoulder bag is made for working professionals and is ideal for official apparel such as commerce suits. Each leather shoulder bag comes with compartmentalized areas that can store up a countless of items which comprise laptops and documents.  The leather shoulder bag is cheap handbags a fashionable result for those who are required to take community convey such as trains and buses to work. Its compact size can assist users keep their stored items left from turbulent moments during travel. The shake allows users to simply expand entrance to items within the leather shoulder bag. To store original items the user must simply unlock the shake and store the necessary items within the appropriate compartment for later use.  A leather shoulder bag is also a chanel handbags wonderful gift for teenagers and adults alike. Its realism makes it the great result for almost any kind of situation. It can be stored in a desk drawer when not in use thanks to the foldable characteristics of the leather shoulder bag.So the charm of the lady is personality catches my eyes first and the high quality, chic design with affordable price of Tory Burch bag keep me stay there. It is a wonderful thing to have several goods from this brand and I promise you won it got disappointed! I have the great faith in the future development of this brand. Way To Go, Tory Burch, to embrace a brighter nfl jerseys for sale future!

  21. Chanel Handbags

    August 13, 2012 at 8:06 am

    In That Respect Chanel Wallet is a wide Chanel Sunglasses range ready for Chanel bags choice including the Chanel Outlet Store black leather satin Chanel Outlet bag. 

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply